Even the best software fails without reliable support. This comparison focuses on how Checkr and First Advantage handle customer service, onboarding, and ongoing help -- because when something breaks, response time matters.
Quick Overview
| Factor | Checkr | First Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Mid-to-large portfolios | Small-to-mid portfolios |
| Support | Competitive | Competitive |
| Mobile App | Yes | Yes |
| Free Trial | Available | Available |
| Support | Chat + Email | Phone + Email |
| API Access | Yes | Yes |
Checkr Support Strengths
Learn more: Checkr vs First Advantage for Property Managers: In-Depth Background Check Services Comparison
Checkr has built a strong reputation in the background check services space. Here is where it stands out:
- Dedicated onboarding specialists for new accounts
- Extensive knowledge base with video tutorials and guides
- Live chat support available during business hours
- Active user community forum for peer-to-peer help
First Advantage Support Strengths
First Advantage brings its own set of advantages to the table for background check services professionals:
- Phone support available on most plans
- Fast average response times reported by customers
- Regular webinars and training sessions for users
- Dedicated account managers for higher-tier plans
Key Differences
Learn more: Checkr vs First Advantage for Property Managers: In-Depth Background Check Services Comparison
Support quality can make or break your experience with background check services tools. Checkr leans toward self-service resources and chat, while First Advantage emphasizes direct human contact. Neither approach is universally better -- it depends on how your team prefers to get help.
Research shows NARPM reports the property management industry manages over $80 billion annually.
When evaluating Checkr vs First Advantage, consider these decision factors:
- Portfolio size: The right fit changes significantly depending on how many units you manage
- Budget: Total cost of ownership including implementation, training, and ongoing fees
- Team size: Solo landlords vs. multi-person property management teams have different needs
- Growth plans: Where you are today vs. where you expect to be in 2-3 years
Who Should Choose Checkr?
Larger property management companies benefit from Checkr structured onboarding programs and dedicated customer success resources.
Checkr is the stronger choice if you need:
- Advanced reporting across multiple properties or ownership entities
- Enterprise-level integrations with your existing tech stack
- A platform with a proven track record at scale in the background check services market
- Dedicated customer success support for complex implementations
Who Should Choose First Advantage?
Independent landlords and small teams often prefer First Advantage direct phone support, which is faster when you are managing everything yourself.
First Advantage is the better fit if you need:
- A faster path to value with minimal setup time
- More straightforward pricing without enterprise-tier commitments
- A platform tailored to independent landlords or growing property managers
- Strong peer community support and accessible self-service resources
Bottom Line
Before choosing, test both platforms support by submitting a pre-sales question. Response time and quality will tell you a lot about what to expect post-buy.
Both Checkr and First Advantage are legitimate contenders in the background check services space. The best choice is the one that matches your current operation and supports where you are headed. Take advantage of free trials, speak with current customers if possible, and do not make a rushed decision on software you will rely on daily.
The True Cost Comparison: In-House Admin vs. a PropertyManagementBiz VA
Managing Checkr or First Advantage in-house means every administrative task falls on your team. Here is how the numbers compare when you bring in a dedicated VA instead:
| Factor | In-House Admin | PropertyManagementBiz VA |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $3,500-$5,500 | $1,200-$2,000 |
| Annual cost | $42,000-$66,000 | $14,400-$24,000 |
| Ramp time | 4-8 weeks | 48-hour match |
| Contract terms | Employment contract | No long-term commitment |
| Software training | You arrange it | Pre-trained in major PM platforms |
| Scalability | Hire again to grow | Add capacity without new headcount |
The math is straightforward. A trained VA handles the same daily software workflows at roughly one-third the cost, with no benefits overhead and no lengthy onboarding cycle.
How a PropertyManagementBiz VA Maximizes Your Software Investment
Choosing between Checkr and First Advantage is one decision. Getting full value from whichever you pick is another challenge entirely.
A dedicated property management VA handles the daily workload your software requires:
- Entering new lease agreements and updating tenant records in real time
- Processing maintenance requests and tracking resolution status through to completion
- Running monthly owner reports and distributing statements on schedule
- Following up on late payments and logging all tenant communications
- Coordinating vendor invoices and reconciling payment records each month
The outcome: Your chosen platform runs at full capacity, response times improve, and you reclaim 12-15 hours per week for business development and owner relationships.
PropertyManagementBiz matches property managers with dedicated VAs within 48 hours. Every VA is pre-trained in AppFolio, Buildium, and Rent Manager. No long-term contracts. No benefits overhead. Trained capacity that scales with your door count.
💡 Did you know? Property managers who delegate software-heavy admin tasks to a trained VA report reclaiming an average of 12-15 hours per week for higher-value work.
Get a Free Consultation to match with a VA ready to work in your platform from day one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Checkr or First Advantage better for property managers?
The best choice depends on your portfolio size and workflow. Checkr typically suits larger operations needing deep reporting and complex integrations. First Advantage is often preferred for faster onboarding and a shorter learning curve. Request demos from both and speak with users at your portfolio scale before deciding.
What are the main differences between Checkr and First Advantage?
Checkr and First Advantage differ in pricing model, implementation complexity, and feature depth. Checkr offers more customization and integration options for complex portfolios. First Advantage is generally more accessible for smaller teams or operators who prioritize simplicity. Evaluate both against your current workflow and three-year growth plan.
Can a virtual assistant manage Checkr or First Advantage for my property management company?
Yes. A property management VA pre-trained in major platforms handles daily data entry, tenant communications, and reporting in either system. This frees you to focus on portfolio growth instead of software administration tasks that do not require your direct attention.
Which platform is easier to implement: Checkr or First Advantage?
First Advantage typically requires a shorter setup timeline, often 1-2 weeks, compared to Checkr which may need 4-8 weeks for full deployment. Your team's technical capacity, urgency, and available internal bandwidth should guide the decision.
Compare more background check services tools at PropertyManagementBiz.com